Find Your Perfect Indianapolis Dating Site

Looking for love, romance, and butterflies in Indy? We've got you sorted with the Best10 independent reviews, ratings, and insights into the top dating apps in Indianapolis.

Displaying our pick of the Best Indianapolis Dating Sites

More Choice?
Site
We Think
Our Score
Visit Site
Most Popular

One of the original dating sites, focused on serious, long-term romance.

One of the original dating sites, focused on serious, long-term romance.

Today's Top Choice
Visit SiteVisit Site
Compatibility Matching
Mobile App
Serious Relationships
Premium Pricing
Great Value

Fun and easy-to-use dating website

Fun and easy-to-use dating website

Today's Top Choice
Visit SiteVisit Site
40m Members
Mobile App
Age: 25-45
Premium Deals
Best On Mobile

Intelligent Matchmaking for Single Professionals.

Intelligent Matchmaking for Single Professionals.

Today's Top Choice
Visit SiteVisit Site
Intelligent Matching
Mobile App
Age: 35-65
Premium Options
For Over 50s

Offers online dating to the ever-increasing 'mature' (50+) age group

Offers online dating to the ever-increasing 'mature' (50+) age group

Today's Top Choice
Visit SiteVisit Site
Stress-Free Dating
Mobile App
Age: 50+
Premium Options
Find Your Perfect Indianapolis Dating Site

How We Select the Best Indianapolis Dating Apps

There is so much more to online dating than creating a profile and waiting for the messages to flood in! And the quality and features of your chosen Indianapolis dating site will greatly impact your likelihood of finding a match.

Best10DatingGuide is 100% independent, and we make it our business to trial each of the top dating sites in Indiana, review them with a detailed checklist of criteria, and assign a rating based on our experiences and the comparable dating options out there.

How do we decide which Indianapolis dating sites get the gold star of approval?

Our dating experts investigate each site and analyze what they offer in terms of:

  • Value for money and subscription costs.
  • User-friendly features and search tools.
  • Messaging functions and video chats.
  • Suggested matches or matchmaking.
  • Security and user ID protection.
  • Mobile usage and the availability of an app.
  • User demographics and local membership base.
  • Dating niche or target user profiles.

When we recommend an Indianapolis dating site, it means we've created our very own profile, trialed and tested each page, and decided that it deserved a spot in our top ratings!

Whenever a new contender steps into the ring, we go through the same rigorous analysis and often update our ratings when we find a fresh dating service, so keep an eye out for new suggestions and even a discount code or two.

Choosing the Right Indianapolis Dating Site for You

The right dating site for you will depend entirely on the type of relationship you're looking for and whom you'd like to meet!

For example:

  • Do you want a short-term casual romance or a long-term commitment?
  • What age, sexuality, career, lifestyle, and aspirations will your ideal partner have?
  • Is it important that your date lives close to your home address?
  • Are you hoping to meet a date with similar hobbies as you?
  • Would it make a difference if your date was also a single parent, a professional, or had been through a divorce (and understands your situation!)?

That's just a snippet of the questions we suggest you consider before selecting your perfect dating site. Everyone will have preferences and deal breakers, so we can't choose one amazing Indianapolis dating site and assume it'll work for every person in Indiana!

Best10DatingGuide splits our reviews into locations and categories so you can jump right to the dating site ratings most relevant to you.

You can browse single parent, senior, plus-size, Christian, divorced, professional, casual, LGBTQ+, or mainstream dating rather than spending time checking out dating sites that won't help you move your relationship goals forward.

Once you've worked out what a great relationship will look like, you'll be in a solid position to pick the most suitable dating category, select from the top-rated Indianapolis dating apps, and get stuck in!

Indiana Online Dating Security Tips

Online dating can be a convenient and relatively fast way to meet new people, set up a few dates, or even start networking and meeting people in your local area (particularly if you've recently moved!).

However, we always need to be mindful of online security. Even the best possible Indianapolis dating apps could have a few fake profiles or scammers knocking around, so it's up to you to exercise caution and remind yourself of the basic dating rules.

Here are a few tips:

  • Only use an online dating site with good security controls. We prefer ID verification because, although it takes a few minutes, you can have confidence that everyone on the site is who they say they are.
  • Don't chat to anybody with an odd profile photo - say a plant or their dog. It's not only a little unusual but also a red flag that there's probably a reason the person behind the profile doesn't want to share their image.
  • Share just the information that is relevant to your dating profile. Some people love the opportunity to wax lyrical about their personality, but it invites trouble! Your work address, home address, phone number, commuting route, or regular gym aren't things people online need to know about.

Finally, use the block and report functions if you encounter anyone acting suspiciously or who sends you messages you haven't consented to receive.

They're there for a reason, and the dating site admin will be grateful for the opportunity to remove a profile that doesn't comply with the platform usage rules.

Disclosure: This website is an independent comparison site that helps consumers find the most suitable product for their needs. We are able to maintain a free, high-quality service by charging an advertising fee to featured brands whenever a user completes a purchase. These advertising fees might impact the placement of the brands on this page and combined with the conversion rates might impact the scoring as well which are further based on a combination of review findings, user experience and product popularity. We make best effort to present up-to-date information; however, we do not compare or include all service providers in the market.

Best Dating Sites Near You